Welcome to our in-depth review of Benchmark Old Number 8, a bourbon that has been making waves in the whiskey world for its exceptional balance of quality and affordability. Hailing from the renowned Buffalo Trace Distillery, this bourbon brings a rich heritage and a flavor profile that appeals to both casual drinkers and serious connoisseurs. Whether you’re a newbie to the bourbon scene or a seasoned aficionado, Benchmark Old Number 8 promises an intriguing blend of smoothness, sweetness, and just the right touch of spice.

Join us as we delve into what makes this bourbon a standout choice, from its fascinating origins to its versatile enjoyment. Whether you’re sipping it neat, on the rocks, or as the base of your favorite cocktail, Benchmark Old Number 8 is set to impress with its rich flavors and accessible price point. Let’s explore the world of bourbon together through the lens of this distinguished spirit.

In-Depth Review of Benchmark Old Number 8

Benchmark Old Number 8, a standout bourbon from the Buffalo Trace Distillery, excels in the competitive whiskey market through its unique combination of quality and affordability. Named in homage to the McAfee brothers, pioneers of the Kentucky landscape, this bourbon carries a heritage that is both rich and intriguing, making it an attractive option for a wide audience, from casual drinkers to serious connoisseurs. At the heart of Benchmark Old Number 8 is its celebrated smooth and approachable flavor profile.

Distilled using Buffalo Trace’s proprietary mash bill, which remains a closely guarded secret, it is believed to be high in corn, with rye and malted barley adding complexity. This results in a bourbon that is sweet with notes of caramel and vanilla, complemented by a hint of rye-induced spice. The aging process in new, charred oak barrels not only gives the bourbon its inviting amber color but also enriches its flavor with depth and character.

The aroma of Benchmark Old Number 8 is notably inviting, showcasing caramel, oak, and a touch of fruitiness, leading into a palate that is both rich and velvety. The medium-long finish ensures a satisfying warmth with a residual sweetness, subtly accented by spice. This balance of flavors renders it exceptionally versatile, perfect for enjoying neat, on the rocks, or as the foundation of beloved bourbon cocktails, such as the Old Fashioned or Manhattan.

Critically, the affordability of Benchmark Old Number 8 does not compromise its quality. It stands as a shining example of Buffalo Trace Distillery’s dedication to producing high-quality spirits that are accessible to a wide range of consumers. This bourbon is an excellent introduction for those new to the spirit while still offering sufficient complexity to engage seasoned aficionados.

In summary, Benchmark Old Number 8 delivers exceptional value, offering a harmonious blend of sweetness, spice, and depth. Its rich heritage, paired with a smooth and inviting flavor profile, establishes it as a distinguished choice within its category. Whether you are just beginning your bourbon journey or are a dedicated enthusiast, Benchmark Old Number 8 presents a compelling experience that celebrates the craft of American whiskey-making.

Distillery: Where Is It Made?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon is meticulously crafted at the Buffalo Trace Distillery, nestled in Frankfort, Kentucky. This distillery stands as a pillar of American whiskey history, boasting over two centuries of distilling expertise. Known for its unwavering dedication to quality and innovation, Buffalo Trace Distillery has earned a prestigious reputation, producing a diverse portfolio of award-winning spirits.

Kentucky map with Buffalo Trace Distillery location
Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon Review – Distillery

The production of Benchmark Old Number 8 within these hallowed halls ensures that each bottle captures the essence of the distillery’s rich heritage and masterful craftsmanship, making it a true embodiment of American whiskey excellence.

Distillation & Aging: How Is It Made?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon is crafted through a precise distillation process at the Buffalo Trace Distillery. The bourbon starts with a proprietary mash bill, rich in corn for sweetness, with rye and malted barley adding a layer of complexity and spice. Following distillation, the spirit is aged in new, charred oak barrels.

This aging phase is critical, as it not only bestows the bourbon with its inviting amber hue but also deepens its flavor, introducing nuances of caramel, vanilla, and oak. The interplay between the carefully selected grains and the meticulous aging process ensures that Benchmark Old Number 8 stands as a testament to the rich tradition and expert craftsmanship synonymous with Buffalo Trace Distillery.

Nose: What Does It Smell Like?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon unveils an aroma that is both inviting and complex, capturing the essence of traditional bourbon craftsmanship. Upon first scent, sweet caramel and vanilla dominate, embodying the classic bourbon profile. These initial notes are seamlessly followed by the rich warmth of oak and a delicate hint of fruitiness, layering the bouquet with additional complexity.

Man sniffing whiskey highlights aromas: caramel, vanilla, oak.
Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon Review – Nose

This aromatic introduction promises a rich flavor experience, perfectly setting the stage for what Benchmark Old Number 8 has to offer to both the novice and the aficionado.

Palate: What Does It Taste Like?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon unfolds on the palate with a rich and smooth flavor profile, capturing the essence of its well-crafted nature. The initial sweetness, characterized by caramel and vanilla, seamlessly transitions into a gentle layer of spice from the rye, offering a delightful contrast that enriches the tasting experience. As the flavors develop, subtle notes of oak emerge, lending depth and complexity to the bourbon.

Man savoring whiskey with flavor notes listed.
Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon Review – Palate

This intricate balance of sweetness and spice, coupled with the bourbon’s smooth texture, positions Benchmark Old Number 8 as a versatile and engaging choice for both newcomers and seasoned bourbon aficionados alike.

Finish: What Is The Aftertaste Like?

The finish of Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon is marked by a medium-long aftertaste that gracefully encapsulates the essence of the bourbon’s character. The warmth of the alcohol provides a comforting, soothing sensation, while the interplay of residual sweetness and subtle spice continues to dance on the palate. This aftertaste achieves a delicate balance, ensuring that the concluding experience is neither overpowering nor ephemeral.

Man enjoying whiskey with flavor notes description.
Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon Review – Finish

The lingering flavors of caramel and vanilla, with a whisper of oak, serve as a testament to the bourbon’s rich profile and meticulous craftsmanship, making the finish a defining component of the Benchmark Old Number 8 tasting journey.

My Personal Thoughts

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon truly stands out for its harmonious balance of flavors and outstanding value. Its smoothness and the rich tapestry of flavors, marked by sweet caramel, vanilla, and a subtle hint of spice, position it as an exceptional choice within its price bracket. The bourbon’s versatility is another highlight, making it equally enjoyable whether sipped neat, on the rocks, or as a foundational element in a variety of cocktails.

Originating from the esteemed Buffalo Trace Distillery, the craftsmanship and heritage imbued in every bottle of Benchmark Old Number 8 add deeper layers of appreciation. Personally, I regard it as an excellent gateway for those venturing into the world of bourbon, yet it retains enough complexity to captivate seasoned enthusiasts. Its blend of affordability and quality make it a constant presence in my collection, and it’s a bourbon I enthusiastically recommend to friends and fellow aficionados alike.

Flavor Profile

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon is distinguished by its inviting and rich flavor profile. At its core, the sweetness of caramel and vanilla provides a warm, comforting base, while a layer of spice from the rye adds complexity and intrigue. The bourbon’s maturation in new, charred oak barrels introduces depth and a subtle oakiness, enriching the overall taste.

This harmonious blend of flavors ensures a bourbon experience that is both engaging and well-balanced, making Benchmark Old Number 8 a standout in its category.

Who Would I Recommend It To?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon is a versatile spirit that caters to a broad audience. For beginners venturing into the bourbon world, its approachable complexity and smoothness serve as a perfect introduction. Connoisseurs will find delight in its nuanced flavor profile and the craftsmanship behind its production, recognizing it as a worthy addition to their collections.

Its affordability and versatility in mixing make it an ideal choice for casual drinkers and cocktail enthusiasts alike, offering a high-quality bourbon experience without breaking the bank. In essence, Benchmark Old Number 8 is a bourbon that appeals to a wide spectrum of tastes and preferences, making it a commendable recommendation for anyone looking to explore the rich landscape of American whiskey.

Price: How Much Does It Cost?

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon stands out for its exceptional affordability, making it a highly accessible option within the bourbon market. This bourbon is a testament to Buffalo Trace Distillery’s dedication to providing remarkable value for money, allowing a broad spectrum of whiskey enthusiasts to enjoy a premium bourbon experience without the premium price tag. Whether you are a beginner venturing into the world of whiskey or a seasoned aficionado in search of an everyday bourbon that doesn’t compromise on quality, Benchmark Old Number 8 offers an economical choice without sacrificing flavor or craftsmanship.

The Best Ways To Enjoy Benchmark Old Number 8

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon excels in its versatility, offering a multitude of enjoyable ways to experience its rich flavor profile. Enjoying it neat or on the rocks allows one to fully appreciate the bourbon’s intricate notes of caramel, vanilla, and a hint of spice. For those who favor cocktails, Benchmark Old Number 8 acts as an exceptional base for classics like the Old Fashioned and Manhattan, where its smoothness and balanced flavors contribute to a superior cocktail experience.

Additionally, pairing this bourbon with food—especially dishes that echo its sweetness and spice, such as barbecue or a rich chocolate dessert—can amplify both the bourbon and the culinary flavors. Whether sipped straight, mixed into a beloved cocktail, or accompanied by a complementary meal, Benchmark Old Number 8 offers a versatile and satisfying bourbon experience.

Food Pairings

Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon shines when paired with foods that complement its rich flavor profile. The bourbon’s caramel and vanilla notes harmonize beautifully with the smoky taste of barbecued meats, creating a delightful balance of sweet and savory. Its subtle spice can also enhance the experience of chocolate desserts, adding an intriguing depth to sweeter fare.

For those looking to explore a more adventurous pairing, sharp cheeses offer a contrasting intensity that pairs wonderfully with the bourbon’s complexity, making for an unexpectedly perfect match.

Cocktails

Benchmark Old Number 8 is a versatile bourbon that lends itself well to a variety of cocktails. Its smoothness and balanced flavor profile make it an ideal candidate for a classic Old Fashioned, where its inherent sweetness is complemented by a dash of sugar and bitters. In a Manhattan, the bourbon’s subtle spice is accentuated, providing a robust base that melds seamlessly with the vermouth.

For a lighter, more refreshing option, consider using it in a Whiskey Sour, where the tartness of lemon juice beautifully offsets the bourbon’s richness, demonstrating its adaptability across both classic and modern cocktail recipes.

Benchmark Old Number 8 vs Evan Williams Black Label

When comparing Benchmark Old Number 8 Bourbon to Evan Williams Black Label, key differences highlight the distinct character of each bourbon. Benchmark Old Number 8 is celebrated for its smoothness and the rich notes of caramel and vanilla, presenting a slightly sweeter palate that appeals to a broad range of bourbon enthusiasts. Its versatility shines whether enjoyed neat or as the base in a variety of cocktails, making it a go-to for its balanced flavor profile.

Benchmark vs Evan Williams bourbon bottles comparison
Benchmark Old Number 8 vs Evan Williams Black Label

Conversely, Evan Williams Black Label is known for its robust character, marked by a stronger influence of oak and a noticeable hint of spice. This gives it a bolder taste preferred by those seeking a more pronounced whiskey experience, distinguishing itself in both mixed drinks and straight servings. From a pricing perspective, both bourbons offer affordability, with Benchmark Old Number 8 often being the more budget-friendly option, providing excellent value for its quality.

Ultimately, the choice between Benchmark Old Number 8 and Evan Williams Black Label boils down to personal preference in flavor and drinking style, with each bourbon offering a unique tasting journey to its aficionados.